I've been coming to Toby's for years and yeah the establishment isn't the nicest, especially the back area but I still love it. The wings are in my top 5 of Toronto and an added bonus is that they come with fries. People rant and rave about Duff's, St Louis but the wings at Toby's are better in my opinion. They're a good size (not super steriod looking) and they're nice and saucy. The servers are nice and they can take a joke.
On cheap pitcher night there is nothing to complain about except for the occasional loud and obnoxious group which happens in most bars/restaurants.
The other food on the menu is pretty average. I've had the nachos and a burger but the jewel of this place is the cheap wings and cheap booze. If you're looking for a low key fun night then I'd highly recommend Toby's.