I'm giving this 4 stars for the atmosphere and the carousel. I could spend all day in there looking at stuff. I hear the ice cream is really really good but was too full to get any. The fried pickles were very good but....our meals were just...mediocre at best. I ordered the Chicago dog and the bun was toasted. Toasted? It should've been steamed. My dad had the patty melt and said it was just ok. Very small portions for the price. With this being said though, I would go back. My 2 year old had a ball there and I would to look around some more.