I've never had a bad meal here. The crazy thing is that the burgers are a close second to their salads. I ordered a salad for takeout one day and after I got back to work and devoured it, I realized they are no joke.
On my most recent visit I had the burger topped with pot roast and gravy. I normally order my burger med rare but here it's red center, pink center or ? In any case, what I received was more leaning towards well done. I'm not going to knock them for that because it was still juicy and had good flavor. The gravy, cheese, onion curls and horseradish cream was the true icing on the cake so to speak and the flavor of the roast was just ahhhhmazing. I'm not a person who loves fries but I found myself eating all if them here and looking for more...thank God I have girlfriends who share! ;) The $8 tiny margarita was sooooo tiny but it was refreshing. I enjoyed the fresh juices they used and it was a standout from some of the other margaritas made from prepackaged mixes which are served around the area. I capped off my meal with a nutter butter fluffer (whatchamacallit) shake to go. It was good but I will say the texture of the crushed cookies got to me after a couple sips. I think it could do with less cookie and still be very good. It started to get a bit gritty.
So, why 3 stars? Well, our server was a tad bit tacky. For example, reaching over our foods right in our faces in mid conversation. No excuse me or pardon me and it was weird/awkward. We needed takeout boxes and she put them down in front of my friend on the opposite side of the table and almost took off her face when she did it. The other issue is their floor. It's not just this Burgatory either, I've been to the one in Robinson too and it's the same. It's slippery as heck so don't wear heels. Thank God I didn't wear them today. Even in flats I had to be extremely careful.
It's been over a year since my last visit to Burgatory prior to the other evening. While I can't say I will never visit again, there's nothing making me want to immediately visit again.