I haven't been to the other poke place yet so I'm not going to say one place is better than the other... but I guess the problem is I have been to Hawaii multiple times and have eaten my fair share of poke there, and this place just didn't do it for me.
First of all, traditional poke. White rice + a copious amount of raw fish. Not salad. Not tortilla chips. Ditch the toppings that don't belong. Don't need fancy sauces to top it off. Second, can they be any more stingy with the protein? The scoop is the same size as my small cookie scoop at home. I got a tiny smear of masago as they used a knife to scoop it out... not even a spoon! I don't know how anyone can be full even eating the large bowl. I know seafood is expensive and we are in land-lock Alberta, but my bowl was nowhere near satisfying. As far as taste goes, you pick your own sauce and veggies and they toss it up for you.
The only reason I'm giving two stars was because of the stellar and friendly service.