My middle name is pizza...or at least I wish it was!
When I first moved to Madison, this was one of the first places I ate at. I wasn't disappointed :) They have really quirky pizza selections, which can be fun to try every now and then to spice things up (particularly if you're a pizza addict like me!) However, you can order whatever kind of pizza you want if you're not into trying something different. The Roman Candle was tasty, but beware of the peppers if you're not into spicy foods.
My middle name is also ice cream and they have that here too! The espresso oreo is the bomb. Be sure to join the birthday club so you can get a free beer on your special day. Make sure to get the Spotted Cow!
p.s. The music selection is rad--the waiters/waitresses seem to make up their own mixes which can then be enjoyed by hipster/punk/nerdy customers like myself.