We have visited both the location in Surprise and the location in Arrowhead on several occassions and have never been disappointed. As others have mentioned, the complimentary bread and dipping oil is wonderful. I could make a meal of that alone with a bottle of wine. ;-)
Some of the things we have had....Bruschetta Romana = good, Firecracker Rolls = husband likes, not my favorite, Roasted Brussels Sprout Beet Salad = LOVE, Calzone = Husband loves, Kid's calzone = son orders every time, Italiano Sandwich and Buffalo Chicken Ceasar Sandwich = my adult daughters love.
My personal favorite meal would be the bread followed by the Roasted Brussels Sprout Beet Salad and The Amalfi Thin & Crusty pizza served with a nice bottle of red wine. I have had some of their pasta dishes as well and they were all very good.
I have never tried their spaghetti and meatballs. I make those at home and can't see paying someone else to make them for me. :)
The Italian Sodas are a hit with the kids!