The curds are great. The sandwiches are good. They have a meat raffle (what's that? you'll just have to go to find out). Beer is always great and they mix a mean cocktail.
It's a busy restaurant, so the wait can get a little long at times. I guess that's not a good reason to deduct a star, but I'm an impatient person and there are equally good options nearby.
But really, get the curds. Second best in Madison.