If my review were based on food alone, it'd be 4, maybe 5 stars. But the service really drags it down and makes the whole experience a huge waste of time.
The place is small, so you've gotta wait. No big deal. The problems began when we were seated at a table with, what amounted to, half of a pizza (in scraps and crumbs) on the floor.
Next, the service was awful. Parts of orders were wrong, there was zero eye contact, and lots of rushing around to get back to a conversation with a friend. Not cool. Everything took FOREVER. On a busy night, I expect to wait a little for food if the kitchen gets swamped. I don't expect to wait 15 minutes for a water. This guys also had the personality of a goldfish. Clearly, any service industry job is just not for him.
The pizzas we had were very tasty. Nothing to complain about. Food was mostly hot and the portions were adequate.
I also had the brownie for dessert. Just skip it. They make yummy pizza but miss the mark on the baked goods.