The burgers were flavorful-- you can really taste the bacon mixed in the patty. Fries were crispy and delicious. Could take or leave the atmosphere, seemed like a "frat boy" kind of hang out. Prices were decent for what you got. Great service. Think they could chill out when it comes to the peanuts.
All in all: Meh. Won't go out of my way to come here again. There are just too many great burger joints in Madison, and this one isn't at the top of my list.