Pros: The pizza. Definitely lives up to the hype. Although I am a huge fan of tomato sauce, I actually preferred the non-red sauce pizza (of the two pizzas I tried). Number 10 was the winner (hold the bacon). Entire cloves of garlic, baked until buttery (in both taste and texture).
The second best part was that they let you do different pizzas on each half. Even the specialty pies, even if they have different sauces. That helps justify the price in my mind.
Con: The number of children running around the (small) restaurant. Many were unruly. Considering this is very "adult" pizza, both in ingredients and price, it was pretty surprising. But, you can get carry out, so that might have to be the workaround. Not a reflection of the restaurant, just the parents who come here.
As other reviews said, have reservations or be prepared to wait. They did allow those waiting to order drinks, but there is no bar or anything.