This place is between a 2 and a 3 in my books although I WANT it to be better. I think that it can get better even! I went last week and got a chocolate chip meringue cookie, it was AMAZING!!! seriously the best meringue I have ever had other than my grandmother's so so so good. It was chewy and perfect. I went a few days later to get some more meringues and they weren't as fresh. They still tasted really delicious but they weren't as chewy. I also got the "everything but the kitchen sink" cookie, and it really wasn't that good. It was hard and tasted stale, I came home to warm it up and it became chewy but still had a stale taste. I think maybe they just make too much baked goods for the amount of people who come by and are left with a lot of stale tasting things? I don't know. But I think it could get better!! Just as long as everything is fresh! I love the decor and everything is really beautiful looking, but the freshness really needs to improve.