If I was basing this review solely on food, I'd give it a two.
In my opinion, the burgers were below average (and I'm obsessed with burgers). We shared the Burger Cellar Burger and the Angry Burger. Of the two, the Angry was better (if you like spice) but neither gave me a foodgasm. Plus the fries and poutine were both barely lukewarm.
When we mentioned the cold fries to the waiter he was extremely apologetic and brought out hot ones immediately. He also comped them. For that reason I'm bumping up my score to a 3. The service was very good and that counts for something in my book.
Still, there's something about the burgers that just didn't thrill me. Sorry y'all.