Bottom line - delicious as evidenced by the need to make reservations well ahead of time.
Service - perfect.
Atmosphere - yes, it is in some kind of row house in Sharpsburg. You don't go here for the atmosphere. They did the best they could with the location. I like the shiny copper bar. On a weeknight the place was booked with mostly older couples and people celebrating special occasions.
Food - everything was perfectly cooked. It has been a few months and I don't remember exactly what we had. I know the fish was delicious as was a creme brulee type dessert. There was not a wrong mouthful. Every bite reminded me of the most perfect example of something my grandmothers would make. So I wouldn't call it cutting edge and I don't think they are trying to be. The local and green are bonuses to the deliciousness. I could eat this food any night.