The Old York is a nice little neighborhood place in an area where there just aren't a lot of nice little neighborhood places. An interesting selection of beers on tap, suprisingly good food, friendly staff, and a great patio in the summer make this place my go-to in the neighborhood. This is a great utility spot - good for quiet beers with pals, a casual dinner (the cuban sandwich is delish) or laid-back sunday bunch.
My only gripe is that the small size can make it difficult to get a seat, although crowds here are inconsistent - on a Saturday night, you never know if you'll be the only one there, or will be left table-less.