I'm at school at CMU, so I've only really been here to drink and to have fun - never for a meal. So, how much you enjoy this place definitely depends on what you're looking for. At night, college kids will flood this place and the atmosphere might get a little... claustrophobic. But, if on the other hand, if you are one of those college kids, Hemingways is definitely a good place to be!
They have really cheap beer pitchers each night and they're really well-known for their 7 dollar shot pitchers. The half-price food there at night is also really good. I especially love the cloggen fries (mmm... bacon)