Short story...get a reservation no matter when you plan on coming.
Long story...this place LOOKS great. When we walked in right at opening it was completely empty. We asked the host for a table for 3 and she looked at us completely confused. She had to go and get someone else to tell us they were almost completely booked with no one there. In the time it took for her to say "well we are almost all booked today" 20 times we could have sat down and had our steaks ordered, about 10 minutes. On top of that no one arrived while we were standing there. There are much better steak places in Cleveland that have more than 5 tables.
Try Urban Farmer it is unreal.