I was at Baldwins this Friday for lunch with my colleagues (a group of 12) and was totally disappointed.
We walked in at 12:41 and our food did not come until a little after 1:30. At one point while waiting I turned around and looked, I realized that 6 other tables did not have their food either (some were there before us!) So when the food finally came after waiting for almost an hour, I was not impressed with my food. I ordered the daily special Fish and Chips - the outside of the fish was hard like rock so half way through I ate only the inside because it was so gross and the fries on the side were all soggy, not hot fresh. My friend ordered the mussel and she said it was not even warm. Our server was rude too and she was not happy when we did not tip her well (personally I tip server based on the service I receive, I don't go by the standard rule.)
To me, Baldwins deserves one star. The only reason I gave 2 is because of the nice patio and it did not take long for our drinks to come. Also,my other colleagues who ordered the flatbread sandwish (or maybe it was a wrap sandwish) said they liked their food. So just to be fair...