I'm going to agree with Liam B on a loving two stars. I've been here at 3pm with a rowdy crew, watching it fill up with the weirdest mix of people, including a ton of American and Ontarians who are underage back home and I guess don't realize they can drink anywhere in Montreal? Just kidding, I'm sure that's why they come to town, and somehow the Peel Pub has just become a destination for questers of this kind. Enjoy this riotous vibe, the weirdly vacant decor, avoid the food and mixed drinks, drink cheap pitchers, go elsewhere for other things, that's my advice. It is what it is!