I've been going to Burgatory for years and it's always my first choice in Pittsburgh for a good burger. I've tried their burgers with beef, bison, elk and crab. All I really enjoyed! I usually like to build my own burger which does add up. By the time I add fries my burger is around $17-$18.
However, I always forget that if you're a fan of just a little pink you have to tell them no pink.
The shakes are always really good too! They do change them up so I was a little sad that the coffee and donut shake wasn't on the menu this trip!