I'm not sure what 'wichcraft is doing as part of the Tom Colicchio Craft restaurant "empire"; it is a fairly spartan atmosphere and decor that probably detracts from the brand more than it adds to it. The prices are fairly high and the service is kind of slow. Nevertheless, the food is pretty delicious, and there's nothing to complain about on that front.
For around $13, I got a panini with delicious roast chicken, roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese, and pesto sauce. It really was a very tasty sandwich; all high quality ingredients that go very well together and were assembled in a delicious, coherent way. Still, I walked away from the experience, slightly unimpressed at the [lack of] ambiance at a Colicchio place and at the 20 cent charge I had to pay for my ice water.