I finally went into this bakery! I purchased two cookies...a chocolate chip one and an iced lemon one with cream cheese frosting.
The cookies tasted bland. They were soft, no chewiness and the chocolate chip had barely any chocolate chips. I gave the lemon one away, and my friend concurred that it was awful.
I may be wrong, but these tasted as if they're made with a shortening (crisco) or a shortening-butter combination. This will make soft cookies, but you sacrifice flavor. In any case, for a dollar-plus a cookie, they should be amazing from a bakery.
The cashier was nice, but offered no suggestions, and just stood and stared until I made a selection. The shop is very tiny and cute.
Maybe their cakes are better, but I don't think I'll be back.