I've been to Crop twice. I loved it the first time, and the second time a bit less so.
My first visit was to their old location in the Warehouse District. I actually preferred the space there than in their new Ohio City location (despite the fact that I love Ohio City). Their old space just felt cozier.
My first visit was with my partner on a Sunday. They had a fantastic family style Sunday menu. Everything we had was amazing. And the cost was incredibly reasonable. The food was of very high quality and was extremely fresh. The service was great too!
The second visit was with a large group for a luncheon around the holidays. Unfortunately the service was lacking on this visit and the food just didn't seem to be of as high quality as on my first visit. That may have been related to the busy holiday season and our large party, but it was a bit disappointing.
With that being said, I would absolutely go back to Crop and recommend it to others. It's a unique and very worthwhile place to checkout! And if you go be sure to try the balsamic popcorn. It's unbelievably delicious.