While I don't live in Cleveland anymore this is definitely a must whenever I am home visiting family. You must try the shwarma hummus, fattouch, and tabbouleh... it does not get better. Their fattouch has sumac which is an essential ingredient that you won't find most places. Their hummus is also totally unique, I have not found a place that can do nearly as good a job- they must use dried chickpeas instead of canned and you can definitely taste the tahini. The lamb shwarma is also perfectly spiced and delicious.
My mouth is salivating just thinking about it.... If you are in the neighborhood this place is definitely worth your while. My family has been coming here for years and the servers are always great- making sure you have enough of everything- despite being swamped. Nate's is definitely worthy of the 5 star Yelp review.