I'll start off by saying the lobster roll was incredible. So why am I not giving this place 5 stars? To start with, $30 for a lobster roll is crazy. The roll came with a single pickle and a salad. They give you so much salad it's as if they are trying to make up for the overpriced lobster roll. I fully expect to pay more for lobster but who wants to go for lunch with a friend and pay almost $80. The lobster in the roll was perfectly cooked with the perfect amount of butter on it. 5/5 for the roll.
The second disappointment, the plates and cups. The plates and cups you get for your meal will take you back to your childhood. You eat off plastic plates and drink soup from plastic cups. This was fine when I was a child and eating jam sandwiches and drinking strawberry milk. When I'm paying so much for a meal I expect nice plates. I wouldn't dream of serving food on these to guests at my house let alone paying customers. I think the owner is trying to keep in with the style of the restaurant which is fun and quirky but this doesn't work at all. The two most important things when serving food, presentation and taste. You can't present nice food on plates that looks like they came from a garage sale.
Because the lobster roll was so good it's the type of thing you tell your friends to try but you know they will only try it once because of the price. If it was slightly cheaper you might have it once every few months as a treat but at its current price, sadly, I won't be returning.