I had no idea what to expect, but I was blown away. The venue is surprisingly small, but it means that every seat gives you a great view of the action, the actors are close enough to read their facial expressions, and I was honestly surprised by the number of set changes and how intelligently they made use of the limited space. The venue doesn't feel as small as it is, once the show starts. The prices are very reasonable, and to be honest I prefer this kind of cozy, intimate setting to the majority of larger theaters I've visited. They also recruit very talented local actors, so it's a great night out to support the local scene. I suppose there's always some room for improvement, but this place made one great first impression on me.
Also found it very endearing for the Christmas Carol production, when the actors went outside to sing carols to everyone as we were leaving. Class act!