I've only been here on nights during the school year and--yikes. The front room is claustrophobic, and though the back isn't as packed, good luck trying to have a conversation at a normal speaking volume. Even though I'm only in my mid-twenties, I feel way old and crochety among the people who clog the place.
As other reviewers have said, you can't beat the price of the beer specials here. The cardiac stix (deep fried provolone sticks) and the spinach artichoke dip (served with deep fried pita bread slices) are pretty decent appetizers to share. The low prices might encourage you to order more, but the waitstaff can be so elusive that you'll just end up asking for your check the next time you see your server.
If cheap beer and food are your top priorities, and atmosphere matters very little, then Hemingway's will do. I'd rather walk a little farther from Pitt and go to Panther Hollow Inn near the corner of Forbes and Craig.