YESSS...! I finally got to try this place out with the siblings yesterday afternoon!
We all ordered 1 arepas each...
Sister had the Wood Fire Chicken Shredded, brother had the Wood Fire Beef, and I had the Carne Asada with avocado and cheese. We also had Fried Plaintains and Fries (LOL). One word: awesome. We pretty much devoured everything, and the mango juice I also had was cool and tasted fresh (ice was unnecessary).
It was pretty clean in there, but it wasn't busy either. Sister said the one Downtown gets overcrowded, so this is a nice change of pace and setting.