I've been to Cabin Club three times now--all for dinner. It's a very small restaurant--literally a cabin, hence the title. Adding to the charm, the staff was very friendly and attentive.
I definitely had no problems with the steak on my first two visits. The third time, however, I went on a mission to compare it directly to XO Prime Steaks where I had lunched a few weeks earlier. Coincidentally, the special that night was a bone-in ribeye--exactly what I had at XO. Almost with regret, I have to say that the XO steak won the match. The Cabin Club bone-in ribeye tasted almost flat by comparison.
The saga continues; I'm sure that these won't be my last visits to these restaurants. I remain a fan of Cabin Club.