Firstly, to all those people who gave bad reviews for 'clutter/messiness': You are NOT true geeks then. Had to get that off my chest. This place is a treasure and it's sad because places like this are becoming harder to find by the day. Never been here before but had heard many great things about the owner and the establishment.
Yes, it is cluttered, but have you SEEN all the one of a kind crap in there?? Yes, it's dusty in the low traffic areas, but look at that dust covered board game and enjoy the free trip back to childhood. The owner is very nice and his prices are fair. He has an ENORMOUS knowledge of trading cards and rulings.
The ONLY reason I'm giving it 4 stars is because I was promised his $20 magic boxes would have a handful of rares/gold cards and there were none. There were a crap ton of silvers/uncommons though..in addition, every one else I talked to did in fact uncover gold/rares.. :-/