I'm a repeat customer of Paymon's, therefore I'm leaning toward 4 stars. Realistically, probably more 3.5 but let's not split hairs.
The hostess was fantastic as soon as we walked in. She was friendly and alerted us to a nice booth that was just opening up, instead of just sticking us at any table.
Our waiter was very familiar with all the dishes and recommended his favorites, as well as commented on the wines we were considering.
Noticed that they have a 1/2 portion menu for a limited time that includes some of their huge portion items (like the Spanakopita).
This evening we opted for the small Indian section of the menu (I know, Indian at a Mediterranean restaurant??) The Chicken Tandoori was very tender and the Mango Chutney dipping sauce superb. The portion was perfect also. The Chicken Curry dish was excellent, although I would have preferred more chicken. That was my only knock on the meal, although for the price I wouldn't say it's a deal breaker.
The atmosphere is quite nice. And for the hookah smokers out there, the lounge is a great stop.
All in all, Paymon's is a great off-strip stop and I will be back.