I've eaten here a few times now and never been disappointed. It's hard for me to stay away from burgers, and the "Tipsy Burger" was fantastic, as are their cheese curds.
They have good nightly drink specials, especially for Fridays ($2.50 shots of Jameson and $3 Ale Asylum pints? Come on!)
The ambiance is good, the wait staff is above average, and the layout of the bar/restaurant is fun.
Overall, I definitely recommend it.