Hmmm I have some mixed feelings about Casey Moore's. The place is always packed so it's definitely a popular spot. I used to come here all the time back in the college days. This time I came here on a busy weekend night around 8 pm for dinner and drinks. There isn't really a system for getting any kind of table so you have to fend for yourself. We were able to get a spot but waiting for a waitress to come took a while. Like I said it was busy but maybe they just need more staff or something. Once we had our server everything was great! We (ok maybe just I) ordered way too much food. I got the scampi shrimp boat, a dozen oysters, and escargot. You get a ton of escargot, not just the six that you normally get in the dish. The size of the shrimp boat was generous as well. Everything was perfectly cooked and the garlic bread was awesome for dipping in the extra garlic butter. The oysters were just ok. I feel like a place that has oyster in the name should have an actual selection of different oysters and they should be served detached from the shell. They didn't have a ton of flavor either so that was a bummer. We ordered oyster shooters as well which was a huge mistake. I don't know what I was expecting but the giant oyster, mix of tomato (?) juice, and the world's cheapest vodka was not pleasant at all.
Casey Moore's definitely caters to the college drinking crowd, especially on the weekends. So I would recommend if you're coming in for dinner to do it on a quieter night where there's hopefully a bit more organization. Also, if you have an aversion to cigarette smoke the patio is not for you. Everyone around us was smoking it makes for an unpleasant dining environment.