I've been looking for a replacement for my dearly departed Gabe's Deli, and, alas I keep looking.
The first time I came here I ordered the Shaved Prime Rib because everyone here was raving about it like it was sent down from heaven on a golden platter. I think that was my first mistake. I like everything that comes on it but it (sadly) just did nothing for me, which didn't surprised me because it's not really something I would have ordered so I can't hold it against Herb 'n Twine. The next time I went I ordered what I wanted to the first time before divine intervention took over- the smoked turkey club. Turkey bacon and gouda is my idea of heaven so this time I was taking my own path to enlightenment. It was okay, but I didn't find it as wonderful as my remarkably hungover roommate did so I let her have the second half for $5 (as any good business woman would do). There's something off about it and I'm not sure if it's the mayo or what. I feel like every sandwich I've ordered has something trendy, and I love trendy, ingredient that throws it off for me. Additionally, I like my bacon well done and crispy but when they say smoked bacon they mean smoked like smoked salmon.
I like that they carry the local Old City Soda and that they make their own pickles. They have a good chip selection and the tomato bisque sounds amazing minus the whole blue cheese thing.
To be honest I'm a bit underwhelmed by Herb 'n Twine but I love the vibe and they get another star because everyone I've brought here seems to really enjoy their sandwiches. Next on my list to try is either the Cuban, Italian, or Chorizo Meatball