I'm a little apprehensive to give this little Gordon Square area gem a "five star" rating only because I don't want the secret to get out and have this place be constantly packed (I'm selfish, I know).
Drinks: Awesome! They have tons of great wine selections by the glass or bottle and they make a great cocktail that a seasoned drinker would undoubtedly appreciate and savor. I would recommend the "Jockey Full of Bourbon".
Atmosphere: This is a wonderful spot for a dinner or even just drinks with work colleagues or a small group of close friends. I would not, however, recommend this place for a large gathering of people unless you reserve the entire restaurant... otherwise everyone else would just end up feeling like they are part of your event whether they wanted to be or not. The interior is well decorated and provides a relaxing and sophisticated (but not fancy) tone. They also have a great patio that carries out the vibe from the interior. I love sitting on patio with a friend, having a drink and casual conversation. You feel like you are at the patio of your friend's house who you love but has annoyingly better taste than you.
Service: Again, awesome! The staff is very knowledgeable of the menu and they seem to know exactly the perfect items to order for every guest that walks through their door.
Food: Good. I would probably give the food four stars for the price. Not to say the food is bad or even mediocre, I would just proceed with caution before ordering the most expensive item on the menu on your first visit.
Toast is a fabulous addition to Gordon Square and is officially on my list of "go to" places when I'm trying to show-off all the amazing things Cleveland has to offer.