My first review was a 4 Star based on a couple slices and included the promise of an update once I ordered a whole pie. Whole pie ordered, 5 Stars awarded! We've gotten the same pizza as carryout twice now. Meatball, pepperoni and onion, cooked well done and both times it was delicious.
I like to heat my slices up in the toaster oven once I get home and that alleviates the issue Ponyboy (Stay Golden Ponyboy) comments on in his 10/1 review. My wife just gobbled it down straight from the box and she was quite pleased.
I did experience the soggy crust with one of the slices on my first visit so, that is something they apparently need to work on but, all in all, I'm quite happy with Rocky's. I just hope the word gets out quickly as it's kind of a weird location connected to a Dunkin Donuts/Baskin Robbins chain and some may not think to give it a chance.