Here is where my best food friend (bff...to me) and I disagree: Classic Italian Pizza.
I think it is alright. It definitely is a place that supports my "treasure hunt" hypothesis to finding great stuff in the Phx (for crying out loud, it is next to a Big Lots!).
I've been here three times, at least (1: with bff, 2: with a date who said he gave a former student/girfriend an "A for the lay" - yeah, that was the 1st and only date - . 3: with Mom and Step Dad). I don't know -- I appreciate the wood fired oven, the totally sweet staff, and the bread, but the food just doesn't quite cut the mustard for me. I suppose all those years in Rome (okay, those TWO years in Rome) really amped up my snob factor.
I would take a picky date here in the future -- because it has good date atmosphere, I couldn't date anyone who couldn't support the TH hypothesis, and who doesn't at least LIKE pizza?