This was my first visit to Phoenix and wasn't certain what to expect from a "historic" hotel in AZ. WOW. I loved the history of the place and the architectual influences of Frank Loyd Wright. Very large property. My husband and I stayed in the Villas - nice with a private bedroom feel and outdoor patio. If I were to return I would reserve a room overlooking the Garden or the Cottage Rooms. Both are packed with history. Definitely a beautiful-unique "historic" hotel in AZ.
On the minus....No in room coffee/maker is unacceptable - particularly given the room service coffee will run you close to $15 w/ surcharges. Patios and furniture in the resort section were not worthy 5-Star Hotel. Grounds around the resort rooms/patios also need luxury spruce-up. Late check-out resulted in 3 different housekeeping staff walking into my room while I was trying to get dress/pack.
All in All - still worth the stay..for the history and beauty of the hotel.