I am not a huge fan of Cicis, I actually dread when my family wants to go so keep that in mind.
I am giving a 5 star review because something really impressed me. They had a lot of pizza and it was dinner so things were moving quickly except for an old peperoni pizza that looked like it had been sitting for a while. What impressed me was when they threw it or and spaced it with a fresh one. Great practice for a buffet.
Food quality is on par for the price. Service was polite.
Update: I've been to cicis 10+ times and tonight I actually liked some the pizzas! Flat vegetarian was great! Everything was hot. Fridays are best.