Maybe it's because it's storefront on Mill, there was a pungent sewage smell walking in. I heard other customers make the same remark. So service was pretty quick. There were plenty of ice cream flavors and cookies to choose from. The price was great, $2! I don't know if I came in the evening, but my cookie was hard. It wasn't rock hard, but if I'm eating an ice cream sandwich, I should be able to take a smooth bite. I pretty much had a messy dessert and the ice cream kept sliding out of the cookie. If you were coming here for something else, I'd say go for it, but not for the ice cream sandwiches. Maybe I'll try it again sometime, but I'll check out other places first.