I've been to the old fashioned a few times and each time is... meh... obviously great beer selection, but that's really about it. Waiting 45 minutes for subpar service and food isn't my thing.
One time we were given a 45 minute wait time, sure, that's fine.. we were seated, and waited another 10 for our server to arrive. Communication issue? Understaffed? Forgot about us? Not sure.. but not impressed.
Cheese curds are decent but in entirety, not my cup of tea when it comes to comfort food.
I may give it another shot, but wouldn't recommend it to others.