Great spot to grab a slice before or after a Badger (insert sport) Game or after sampling the many wares of State Street area bars.
Sometimes the best part of this place is the people watching, as one is guaranteed to see someone drunk do something worth remembering and laughing about later.
As for the pizza, there are plenty of better slices out there, but few for a comparable price. I usually stick with a simple pepperoni and sausage, but the philly steak pizza is pretty good, too. I am not big on the macaroni and cheese pizza, but most people I know love it. I'm a toppings and sauce guy, so it holds no particular power for me. I want to try the brisket and tot pizza, but they have never had it when I was there.
The only reason I don't give the location 5 stars is that the service can be a little uneven. Obviously I am being a bit harsh, because trying to serve a population of drunkards can be challenging at 3am.