The evening started at Oyster Bay. We were there for my Birthday. Reviews were good, and we were expecting fresh seafood. The crab cocktail and shrimp cocktail were over steamed, old and had no flavor. The lobster tail was mushy and my mahi mahi came in a bowl with a watered down marinara sauce. It was like the worse fish stew that I wouldn't eat. The server wanted to bring something different, but he had delayed our order for so long between the appetizer and main course, that we didn't want to sit there for another 45 minutes. Long story short, I don't eat at Red Lobster, but it would have been a drastic improvement.
Save yourself the disappointment. Don't go!