I enjoyed Pizza Pie Cafe, but it's not perfect.
The salad bar which isn't big, but it is sufficient for a pizza buffet. The pasta bar was unexpected with numerous pastas which you pick and they quickly boil and there are a bunch of sauces you can add yourself.
Regarding pizza, the cheese pizza is great, but unfortunately the other pizzas just didn't seem appetizing to me. They looked like they have been there for a bit too long. I tried the BBQ chicken which had pineapple; I've never had pineapple on BBQ chicken, it seemed out of place. The pizza was also a bit dry as it seemed to be out for a while.
I tried the apple and cookie dough pizzas, the apple tastes like an apple dessert pizza from any other place and just pass on the cookie dough.
Overall, I see myself returning sometime in the future to give it another chance as they have potential, maybe lunch on a Saturday is not the best time to come for fresh pizza.