We've been living in the area for 5 years. At our sons 1st birthday party in 2012 we discovered North Side Nathan's (the restaurant previously at this location). Truthfully, we loved North Side Nathan's and were sad when we learned it closed.
When our daughter turned 1 we wanted to order pizza and had the occasion to try Pizza My Dear.
We were more than impressed. I know what you're thinking. "What's there to be impressed about with a neighborhood pizza restaurant? Pizza is pizza." For the most part you'd be right.
What made the experience one that caused me to write this post... And one where we will for sure be returning to Pizza My Dear was the service.
Once the person who answered the phone caught on that we were ordering pizza for a party she took over. She asked, how many adults, how many kids? And she explained to the slice how many pizzas we needed to order based on how big the slices were. The next part was rather comical.
She asked what time we wanted the pizzas delivered. Then my wife and I did the thing where I would yell a question to her and she yell back the answer and all of a sudden were in one of those three way conversations between me, my wife and the nice lady on the phone. So the party was at 5pm. My wife wanted the pies delivered at 3pm (you know... Just in case they were late). The nice lady insisted... "If the party is it 5pm we will deliver at 4:45pm. We really don't want our pizzas sitting out that long." We agreed an ended the call. But not before the nice lady offered to send a complimentary order of their cheese sticks. She didn't have to do that.
At 4:40pm the doorbell rang. Pizzas were in time and they were great. And the cheese sticks were gone first by the way. I recommend them!!