I've been to Esther's 10 times since it opened. My review is based upon a variety of experiences, both at the bar and seated in the dining room.
First of all, the staff is amazing. They are friendly, helpful and the service has been great on each of my visits. Management clearly understands the value of service and IT SHOWS!
Next, the food is awesome. Out of 10 meals, I've had one that I didn't enjoy (it was well-prepared, I just didn't like the flavors). The others have been absolute home runs. The Brick Chicken is amazing. The Bacon, Carmelized Onion pizza is phenomenal. There is always a fresh fish, which is prepared beautifully. I had spaghetti with meatballs recently that blew my mind. The chef focuses on quality ingredients and it shows. And everything tastes so incredibly fresh.
I highly recommend Esther's. The consistent crowds are proof-positive that they are doing something exceptional in the Arts District!
PS - A special shout-out to David at the bar, who always greets me with a smile and a handshake. A true professional...