After twice a day drive-by's and recommendations from everyone and anyone I know, I finally tried Souper Market- and it absolutely lived up to expectations. I got the Chicken Paprikash for lunch and it was delicious and filling. And the bread. Oh the bread. It deserves its own rave review.
For the food, Souper Market gets 5 stars.
The only downsides as far as I can see are: its a bit pricey for what it is ($7 for a lunch size portion of soup), the location and long lines make it hard to get in and out of during lunch, and theres not much seating so there is a good chance you'll get takeout, leaving you with cold soup that needs to be reheated by the time you're back at work/home.
All of the soups on the board looked amazing though and I know I'll be back- we have way too many cold snowy days here in Cleveland not to!