With the caveat that I have only been here once and I've only eaten the steel pan (Detroit style) pizza, I enjoyed it enough that I just can't hold it in.
The crust was thick, but not heavy or dense or greasy and the edges were caramelized and shockingly delicious. I haven't had Detroit style before, so I don't know how it compares to its cousins.
I haven't tried their wood fired pizzas and I don't know how I ever will at this rate.
Also had a plantain desert with caramel and coconut ice cream that was also surprisingly good and much lighter than I expected.
Salvatore's is probably still my favorite pizza in Madison, but Lucille's steel pan is definitely going in my rotation.
That caramelized crust, though.