I think I found my new nail place. It's not a fancy place, and it's not really close to my house, but it's worth the drive.
I came in two weeks ago for a gel polish manicure, and it's still looking pretty good. It has only chipped in one place so far. The girl that did my nails, Sophia, was super nice, quick, and very thorough. I'm usually really iffy about people trimming my cuticles, but she did a great job. The gel polish mani was only $25. They do gel polish pedicures also, and those are only $35. I will definitely be getting one of those next time.