I'm giving Cropicana 4 stars because I was drunk and only remember good things when I'm drunk. There was a band that was playing music that was fun to dance to. And there were the best fried fish sliders I've ever had. (Ok, I've never had fried fish sliders, but they were really, really good.)
Apart from that, I think it's just a big dive bar on the water in kind of a random location to get to (whiskey Island). I was confused when I heard it was the same place as Crop that was on West 6th, because the one time I ate there, I loved that place. But this is nothing like that Crop.