I think this place must have gone down hill since the other reviews were written or the chef quit or something because this place was not good at all. Nothing really stood out as absolutely horrible, but there was just nothing good about it. Plus the prices were outrageous for what it was.
We got escargot for an appetizer and were very disappointed by the quality and quantity of the dish.
My wife got a beef filet and received a very overdone chunk of meat with some fries. When she asked for ketchup the waitress practically rolled her eyes.
I got boeuf bourguignon and it was just not good at all. I'm not very picky when it comes to boeuf bourguignon either. The meat was dry (difficult to accomplish in a stew) and the wine in the sauce tasted like it hadn't been properly reduced.
Our waitress was also not exactly a charmer. Her attitude was the only thing authentically French about the place aside from the price tag.
Go elsewhere, there are plenty of other French cafes in Montreal.